Permanent Life Insurance: A Long-Term Commitment with Flexibility

Permanent Life Insurance: A Long-Term Commitment with Flexibility

‍

The Point of Permanent Life Insurance

The key feature of permanent life insurance is its longevity—it’s designed to last for life. As long as the policyholder keeps up with the required premium payments and avoids depleting the cash value through excessive loans or withdrawals, the policy will remain active until the insured person passes away. Unlike term life insurance, which expires after a certain number of years, permanent life insurance doesn’t have a set expiration date and never requires further medical underwriting once the policy is issued.

‍

The Advantage of Permanent Life Insurance

One of the greatest benefits of permanent life insurance is its guaranteed coverage for life. This can provide peace of mind, knowing that the policy will always be there, no matter how your health changes over time. With term insurance, there’s a risk that if your health deteriorates before the term ends, renewing or purchasing a new policy could become more difficult or expensive. Permanent life insurance avoids that risk altogether.

Additionally, many permanent life policies allow for the purchase of Paid-Up Additions (PUAs), which can increase the death benefit without the need for further medical exams, offering a flexible way to increase your coverage over time.

‍

When Permanent Life Insurance is No Longer Needed

However, life circumstances change. A permanent life insurance policy may no longer serve the purpose it was originally intended for, but because it’s permanent, it remains in force regardless. This creates a situation where the policy might feel more like a financial obligation than a benefit. If your financial priorities shift or if the reasons for initially purchasing the policy are no longer valid, it might make more sense to consider unwinding the policy to free up resources.

For instance, a parent might have taken out a life insurance policy to provide financial protection for their young children in case of an unexpected death. But once the children are grown and financially independent, the need for that policy may diminish. Likewise, someone who purchased life insurance to support a spouse in the event of their death may reconsider continuing that coverage after a divorce. Or, perhaps the policy was meant to build cash value for retirement, but as retirement approaches, other more effective ways of funding retirement expenses become a priority.

‍

Maximizing the Value of a Permanent Life Insurance Policy

Permanent life insurance policies consist of two key components: the insurance portion (the death benefit paid to beneficiaries upon the insured’s death) and the savings portion (the accumulated cash surrender value). If a policy is no longer necessary, the goal is often to retain as much of the savings component as possible while shedding the unneeded insurance portion.

‍

The Tax Implications of Surrendering a Life Insurance Policy

Surrendering the Policy

If you decide that you no longer need your life insurance policy, one option is to surrender it and receive its accumulated cash surrender value. Another option is to sell the policy to a third party through a life settlement or viatical settlement. However, these routes can carry tax implications, particularly when the policy has gained substantial value beyond the total premiums paid. Under IRS rules (IRC Section 72(e)), the cash surrender value received from a life insurance policy may be taxable if it exceeds the total premiums you’ve paid into the policy. This "gain" is taxed as ordinary income. It’s important to understand that surrendering the policy is not treated like selling a capital asset, meaning the entire gain is taxed at your regular income tax rate, which could significantly impact your net proceeds.

‍

Selling the Policy

Selling the policy can sometimes result in a higher payout than simply surrendering it, as a third party might be willing to pay more for the policy due to its potential death benefit. However, the tax treatment is similar to a surrender—the gain is taxed as ordinary income. Additionally, if the sale price exceeds the policy's cash surrender value, the excess is treated as capital gains and taxed accordingly.

‍

Policy Loans: A Flexible but Risky Alternative

‍

Using Policy Loans

If surrendering or selling your policy isn’t the right move, another option to access the policy’s cash value is through a policy loan. This type of loan is issued by the insurance company, with the policy’s cash surrender value acting as collateral. Unlike surrendering, taking a loan allows the policy to remain active, and the cash value can continue to grow. Loans are also tax-free, even if the loan exceeds the amount of premiums you’ve paid into the policy. The appeal of this option lies in its flexibility. Policy loans don’t typically need to be repaid during the policyholder’s lifetime, as the outstanding loan balance is deducted from the death benefit when the insured passes away. However, while this strategy may provide liquidity, it also comes with some risks.

‍

The Risks of Policy Loans

Policy loans accrue interest, and if the interest isn’t paid, it will compound over time, potentially eating into the policy’s cash value and reducing the death benefit. In the worst-case scenario, if the loan balance grows too large relative to the cash value, the policy could lapse. This would trigger the recognition of any taxable gains, resulting in a potentially hefty tax bill with little or no remaining cash to cover it. Policy loans may seem like a flexible funding source, but they require careful management to ensure they don’t become a financial burden.

‍

Partial Surrenders: A Balanced Approach

Partial Surrenders for Gradual Access

For those who want to access their policy’s cash value gradually, partial surrenders may be a more balanced approach. This allows the policyholder to withdraw some of the cash value without fully surrendering the policy or taking out a loan. However, partial surrenders reduce both the policy’s cash value and the death benefit. The tax treatment of partial surrenders is generally favorable. Withdrawals are taxed on a First-In, First-Out (FIFO) basis, meaning the money you initially paid into the policy (your cost basis) is withdrawn first and is not taxable. Only after you’ve withdrawn an amount equal to your total premiums does the IRS begin taxing any additional withdrawals as income. While this strategy provides tax advantages upfront, it does reduce the policy’s ability to grow over time and concentrates the taxable gains into the later withdrawals.

‍

Using a 1035 Exchange: A Tax-Deferred Alternative

‍

Converting to an Annuity with a 1035 Exchange

A 1035 exchange allows a policyholder to convert their life insurance policy into another financial product, such as an annuity, without triggering taxes on any embedded gains. This can be a tax-efficient way to access the policy’s value while maintaining tax deferral. After the exchange, the annuity can continue to grow tax-deferred, and the owner can begin receiving regular payments when needed. This option is particularly beneficial for individuals whose circumstances have changed and who no longer need a large death benefit but could benefit from a steady income stream in retirement. The annuitization of the policy's value spreads out the tax impact over time, making it a potentially more efficient way to manage the proceeds of an unneeded life insurance policy.

‍

Conclusion

‍

Life circumstances often evolve, and a permanent life insurance policy may not always fit your needs as they did initially. Whether you’re considering a surrender, sale, loan, or a 1035 exchange, there are numerous strategies available to optimize the use of your life insurance policy and its cash value while managing potential tax implications. Making the right decision depends on your current financial goals and the future flexibility you need. Always consult with a financial professional to explore the options that best align with your unique situation.